View Single Post
Old 26th April 2017   #25 (permalink)
Josh
(josh1990)
Member
 
josh1990's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Nationality:
Posts: 49
Gallery Images: 0
Comments: 0
Rep: josh1990 has shown reliable knowledgejosh1990 has shown reliable knowledge
Default Re: USARK Lawsuit-THE BAN IS OVER

Quote:
Originally Posted by John View Post
News article in the journal "Science" on latest B.sal news: A deadly salamander disease just got a lot scarier | Science | AAAS

My own thoughts after reading it:

It is missing some current positive information on the fight against this disease, making it a very alarmist/doom-laden article. But fear sells media.

It sounds like (from the end of the article) Joe Mendelson of Zoo Atlanta wants to ban every amphibian coming into the US. In principle, I can see merit to that (that is the current situation with hundreds of salamander species anyhow). But what about the B.sal carrying goose described in the research? Shouldn't we ban geese then? Seriously though, what is reasonable and where would it end?

And then it's important to remember the only known samples of B.sal in the US were imported by US researchers. Remember that studies showed that US researchers carried B.d. to new populations of amphibians in California. And wiped them out. Perhaps we should also ban the importation of diseases into the US for research if they're not already here.
John,
I have not heard the story of the researchers that carried B.d. to new populations in Ca and wiped those populations out! If you could relay the story to me would be great. That should have been in the article but I`m sure they just forgot. Cough-bull-cough...
Josh
josh1990 is offline   Reply With Quote