I wish to add something to Franks comment, which I do partly share, but I guess there's even a bit more to this. When you keep such a species and each year you have offpsring that nobody wants, there 's a downward spinal to breeding as well. Why breed them further if nobody wants them and you're stuck with a few 100 animals ?? Anyway it won't stop me from breeding since I got some room (but now all have this), but if I have to choose which species to breed I will not continue breeding the same species in large numbers each year again...and make a logical choice. So this in itself makes that there is less breeding occuring. Less demand, less breeding , some annual losses arriving... add all of that up and if as an extra feature the species is not that stable : they are gone in the hobby. That's also why we have set up the studbook process and in Holland the KN lists so that we have an idea which species do well.
Since the last annual meeting I have posted myself up for maintaining the KN list for Holland and Belgium and have setup a relational database with a report painter on top for maintaining the data. I have also setup a similar system for studbook maintenance.
Concerning mole salamanders : A. maculatum, A. tigrinum, A. opacum & even tigers are bred (or have been ) in Europe but when offspring is available there is not always that much interest. Some people only want adults ...
Nevertheless I would also want ot mention that there are also people doing a real good job breeding and rearing as well and we shouldn't just stress the negative facts. Some species are really well covered and it is partly due to captive care observations that some traits/facts have been seen for the first and been able to get studied. Just to give some examples : how can you observe evolution of individual juvenile color patterns to adults, the age before reproduction, easy study of some nuptial dance studies ...).
Anyway Tim regarding your initial question (before this gets to be a book) : in the KN list I find 12 people keeping waltl; 8 of them have breeding groups and from time to time breed them, 3 have regular breedings occuring. I think this species is quite safe since it is easy to maintain, breed and long living. But currently there's not a large interest in them . Somebody offering waltl in Holland even wanted to offer his offspring for free.. nobody was actually interested. If thsi would have been the colorful Neurergus ..
Also it is my opinion that somebody really interested in doing a study can do interesting studies with any species: annual growths patterns under various circumstances (temperature a food), different setups with juveniles to study what works best. Defining parameters and setting the data out in a graph... Just maintaining the age of the animals in order to have longevity records ... I know people just keeping one species and doing a great job , I know other peopel holding several species and doing a great job in breeding...
Anyway before anybody asks : I do not intend to offer names of people keeping any species since this is confidential data which I wish to respect. I just wanted to state that there is some view on things and if things go bad we can try to steer (or is it stear ?) this in the right direction (best done through or with the help of the studbookkeeper). At least that's what I would like to realise with this