Cynops chenggongensis

W

william

Guest
looks like livinguderworld has suddenly adopted the same picture if i were to guess a light female c.orientalis maybe...
 
N

nate

Guest
It's definitely not orientalis, it's in the cyanurus group. C. chenggongensis is supposed to have stripes of yellow-orange spots from the shoulder to the tail much like some C. ensicauda ensicauda have.

I do know the animals seen at LivingUnderworld have been shown to Zhao Ermi in China, and he has confirmed them as C. cyanurus cyanurus.
 
W

william

Guest
now i see where your coming from similar to c.e.yunnanensis.

but you never know maybe it really is a chenggongensis and next week they will be giving away free Cynops wolterstorffi with every purchase.
 
A

angus

Guest
Nate,
Did you contact Dr. Zhao Ermi personally or you got the comment from someone else? There is one important thing I want to add to your comment; according to him, there is no Cynops chenggongensis in China; chenggongensis is cyanurus. The Cynops chenggongensis is just a fake species some scientists make up for their flame! Also, according to Zhao, the C. cyanurus is so variable, appearance is not a key factor to identify them.
Furthermore, new species come out from every field trip in China. It could be a new species that Zhao not even know. China is so big and a lot of new species are just waiting to be discovered. Sometimes, it is hard to identify an amphibian to species or even subspecies standard from China; paramesotriton is a good example.
 
P

paul

Guest
Hi Angus,

so what we need are Yunnan Cynops with exakt known origin, to make a genetically analysis, and to describe the species and subspecies new!

Paul
 
A

angus

Guest
Hi! Paul.

The genetic analysis test is already being arranged and I will be informed when the result come out.
 
A

angus

Guest
Oh! One more thing for the record.
Teratoscincus roborowski is originated from China, but our smart China's scientists still think they are just the same as Teratoscincus scincus.
Not until 1994, Lui Wai make a change and the new latin name is T. roborowski which is accepted internationally.
 
N

nate

Guest
Hi Angus, no I do not speak Chinese and was not able to communicate with him personally, but rather a friend of mine did. About chenggongensis being cyanurus...I suspected as much as offspring from the same parents have been showing characteristics of both cyanurus subspecies. I bet genetics confirms this.

As for it being a new species, that's always possible, but the photo in question sure doesn't look like anything other than a cyanurus. It doesn't fit the original description of chenggongensis either. It is interesting to note though, that you know that chenggongensis is not considered real, yet you have them on your website anyway. Why's that?
 
A

angus

Guest
Well, very simple, I don't trust Zhao at all and I know who your friend is. Your friend didn't contact Zhoa personally either, Zhao was on a field trip when I and your friend discuss on this topic.
 
A

angus

Guest
oh! Also, where did you get your original description of chenggongensis? From the "Atlas of Amphibians of China"?
 
N

nate

Guest
Ah, I see.

So why don't you believe Zhao? The animal in question does not resemble chenggongensis at all from the original description other than looking similar to cyanurus. Any other reasons to suspect they are different from cyanurus that aren't readily apparent in the photo?
 
N

nate

Guest
Well, when I say "original description" I mean the original description as presented by Ye, Fei, and Hu 1993; Fei 1999; and Rafaelli 2000.

I have not read Kou and Xing's original Chinese paper.
 
A

angus

Guest
I don't believe him because I have so many Chinese Cynops (properly more than Zhao has even seen in his whole life) and I did spend many hours on studying the difference between the two cyanurus subspecies and chenggongensis. From the study, I find many differences in my study group. The tail, color, the color of center line, length of toes, even the smell. It is really hard for me to say it all here. Can you tell me where you got your original description of chenggongensis?

(Message edited by AngusLee on September 24, 2004)
 
N

nate

Guest
Angus, I can understand suspecting they are not like other cyanurus based on those reasons, but not labeling them as "chenggongensis". How about "suspected new species"?


Should be interesting to see the genetic results for sure.
 
J

jesper

Guest
I must agree with Nate here, if the original description of chenggongensis does not fit your animals they should definitely not be sold as chenggongensis.
If you believe that you have found a new species go ahead and publish an article, we would all be delighted. I really don't get it, if the original description doesn't fit this your own description of your cyanurus-like animals why do you call them chenggongensis?
I'd really like more info on these cynops you have.
 
A

angus

Guest
Well, I believe what I have here is Chenggongensis. I also believe I have some new species in my collection too. China is like Amazon. You will never understand how it is like to be here.

Hey! Nate. Do you mind to have your original description post here, I mean the original one, not the translated one. It is in Chinese, right?
You can scan it and post it here, so we all can see.

Jesper, have you read the original description? or you just repeat what nate said? Has anyone here see a chenggongensis before, even a picture? Also, as matter of fact, I never offer any chenggongensis for sale! They are only sold on request. I believe no beginners will accept my high price for chenggongensis and thus they are the experienced newt keeper who also believe they are buying chenggongensis. They see the pictures too.

Genetically analysis result is interesting to see, but can it provide if it is chenggongensis or not?
 
N

nate

Guest
Angus, I do understand China has undescribed species, particularly in Paramesotriton and Pachytriton. This is easy to see as animals often look much different than any known species. I cannot say that about your chenggongensis photo, it looks just like cyanurus. I have no reason to suspect it is anything else and that's why I've asked you these questions.

Have you not read the description? I don't have the original Chinese in my possession, but I do have Thorn/Rafaelli's 2000 description handy, which was taken from Kou and Xing's 1983 original paper:

"Diffère de C. cyanurus par les caractères suivants: Taille légèrement plus importante, peau lisse, taches sur la queu des femelles; chez plupart des exemplaires, une ligne de taches juane-orange sur les flancs, allant de l'épaule à la base de la queu."

Are you suggesting that this is in error? Do you have any animals with these stripes?

Of course genetic analysis will tell us if they are chenggongensis, assuming chenggongensis even exist.
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • faebugz:
    To raise GH, add calcium carbonate (or tums). What has you doing this?
    +1
    Unlike
  • Slash-GNR:
    Thank you! My tap water is naturally low in GH and KH, and I need to raise it... but I don't want to raise the pH, which is perfect, with coral.
    +1
    Unlike
  • EaglesFan78:
    anyone have firebelly newts forsale message me !!!!!
    +1
    Unlike
  • ShawnJPN:
    Lol
    +1
    Unlike
  • Unlike
  • Isoldelopez:
    Hey all I’m looking for some help.
    +1
    Unlike
  • Isoldelopez:
    How do I create a thread?
    +1
    Unlike
  • Binditheaxolotl:
    LYes? It might be easier if u posted a thread
    +1
    Unlike
  • Isoldelopez:
    Yes, how can I do this? Is it by creating a room? Thank you for your help
    +1
    Unlike
  • Mark.H:
    Hey guys, I suppose this is a foolish question, but will my long-toed salamanders over-eat resulting in obesity?
    +1
    Unlike
  • Kwags:
    what are thoughts on using crushed coral or tufa rocks for resining the ph level in my tank? I have the seachem ph alert and it’s reading 5.4
    +1
    Unlike
  • Chat Bot:
    meowzilla has left the room.
    +1
    Unlike
  • Delaney:
    Hi, I really need some advice about cloudy water in my axlotl tank!
    +2
    Unlike
  • AnimeDan:
    Hi Delaney. Can you be more specific? There are lots of reasons for cloudy water, such as substrate getting kicked up, water hardness, etc. if you don’t have hard water and it doesn’t settle then I’d do a water change and see if that helps.
    +1
    Unlike
  • Caramello:
    Hey guys... Hope you all keeping well... I have 4 fire belly newts and one looks very bloated... I have seperate him and moved him to his own enclosure so he can get better hopefully but I don't have a filter in this specific enclosure. Please can you guys advise if I need to get him one or whether I can leave it? I have read a lot of articles that say they prefer still water and I can change his water frequently keeping it clean. Please advise 😊
    +1
    Unlike
    Caramello: Hey guys... Hope you all keeping well... I have 4 fire belly newts and one looks very bloated... +1
    Top