I have to say I had a similar experience to Auntiejude when my Embry and Jack had babies.
Embry is a chocolatey silver colour with dark spots and white tummy, and I think she is positively gorgeous, and Jack is a Leucistic with the most beautiful white body and little black eyes. They produced over 70 babies, a mix of Wilds, Leucistics and lighter Wilds.
The babies were adorable and I was really lucky to have a good healthy batch. I advertised for homes for them and found that nearly everyone wanted one of each (if they wanted two) or, if only one, a Leucy. I noticed people were referring to the Leucys as 'pink' axolotls, and that it was mainly women who wanted the 'pink' ones. I did tell them that only the gills are pink, and even then, they are only pink when the axolotl moves (Jack's gills are actually quite pale and he spends a lot of time 'napping.') They still seemed to want these axolotls in preference to the WTs despite this.
I think it partly depends on the availability of the types in your location as well as personal preference. If a type is 'rare' in that area it is often more prized. I also think that the Google search for axolotls usually turfs up Wildtypes, so people are interested in the more unusual colours.
To be honest, I love them all. I think Embry is beautiful, and so is Toothless. Jack is wonderfully different, and Gally is a radiant gold. They're like people, with all their different beauties.