Axolotl Gender Question

[Shygirl]

Hello,

I recently got my first two axolotls and I don't even know if they'd be alive for as long as they have been if it wasn't for all the helpful information I found on this forum so thank you

My axies have to be at least 8 inches and I'm just really curious about what their gender is and was hoping some of the more experienced people on here could tell me what they think. Biggest ones I've seen but being from Ontario it really doesn't say a lot because they're so rare here

Thank you for helping me solve this mystery.

Picture 1: Is Axolotl #1
Picture 2: Is Axolotl #2

 

[Shizeric]

They appear to be females.

 

[Crysta]

I agree, they seem to be females, do you have a picture from the 'birds eye view' angle? as pictures can lie having more of them is best to get a better picture.

This article will help you judge for yourself, as you can see better than us.

 

[Shygirl]

I definitely think they are the same gender. I did see that link awhile ago and I have a hard time seeing a huge difference between the two. One just looks slightly bigger than the other. If I ever see an adult male in person I'll probably have an easier time judging for myself in the future.

Here's the best bird eye pics I can get. Hard to do because of the plants.

Pic 1 is from Axolotl #2
Pic 2 is from Axolotl #1

 

[dragonlady]

I would guess females as well, however, some axolotls are late bloomers. Just because they have the dark tips, it doesn't mean they are necessarily showing you their true selves...For example, I bought a golden with dark tips, presented as a female (about 14 mo. old when I got her), rounded body, no lump. About 6 mo. later, she slimmed down and seemingly overnight there appeared the lump.

I can tell you that a male is pretty obvious in my experience, anyway. His lump is considerably larger and it will extend of the sides a little behind his legs. His body and tail are usually longer and more slender than a female as well.

Either way, you have 2 nice looking axies there.

 

[Morrison]

I would say both females.

 

[Shygirl]

They're really fun to have. They really seem to like each other and sleep on top of each other in a hole they dug out in the corner of their tank. I also got to see one of them yawn for the first time last night. Really cute

I have some normal pics of them in my profile where I'm not just trying to target certain "areas" with my camera lol for those who want to see.

So for now at least I will refer to them as females Thank you all for your time and help on this mystery.

 

[Crysta]

I'm still sticking with my original opinion, I think they're female.

pretty axies =D

 

[melfly]

I think they are too young to sex.

Mine didn't show as male til 9 inch and another at 19 months. (i do believe 19 months is the extreme!!)


Mel

 

[Kaysie]

My one male was easily 18 months before I could firmly say he was male. And that was only after one night of his brothers' dropping spermatophores. I went to bed with a clean tank, 2 male axolotls, and 1 unknown; and I woke up with 50 spermatophores and definitely 3 male axolotls.