Facebook?

auntiejude

New member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
3,682
Reaction score
58
Points
0
Location
England
Country
England
Which (if any) axolotl groups and pages do you follow on Facebook? And what is your opinion on the groups and advice given on Facebook?

Personally I find some of the info in some of the axie groups to be a little ..... um...... inaccurate.

Maybe I'm just used to the excellent advice and info available here :cool:
(oh, and while I'm on the subject I would be grateful if some of you would go and like my page: Billie's Page)
 
I only follow one finnish axolotl group (aksolotlit, if any finns happen to come across this). The advice there is usually pretty good, but some people there have pretty set minds about what is good and what is not, leaving no space for discussion and honestly some times they're just wrong. And as there is only one even somewhat serious breeder in Finland, some people seem to think that only what she says is right and everyone else is wrong. I once told someone there to give her axie earth worms and got a few angry people telling me how wrong I was and that it's the same as if I was feeding my axies chicken or something. I gave them some info about the nutritional values etc, but nothing changed their minds until the breeder came on and said earth worms are ok. I guess it's too hard for them to use their own brains...
 
I follow Billy's page already ;) Super cute photos :D

Axolotl-Aholics is a group I've recently joined with some mixed feelings - a lot of the stuff is helpful but I have been bothered by some of the things I've seen as well... mostly good though.

Still come here for any advice I may need. :p
 
I'm admin of axolotl-aholics. I'm pretty sure my advice isn't that inaccurate?? But there are others there that have just got no clue.. I do my best to make sure wrong info isn't given. But I'm currently the only active admin there..
It's the same as most groups and forums, there's disagreements and debats but what place doesn't have that when everyone has their own opinions and ideas.
 
I probably should have stated better - the things that bothered me weren't from admin or anything - it was posts from members that was inaccurate... and I'm most comfortable asking questions here due to that - because I know who does and who doesn't know what they are talking about.

Didn't mean to insult the group at all! Sorry if I did! <3
 
Some of the fb groups are utter ****. Basic care advice like temperature and cycling tanks is generally OK , apart from that incorrect/dubious info is standard, people with little experience in axolotls dispensing their googled " knowledge" to other clueless clowns. There are some exceptions "The axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum)" run by Patrick Steinberger is excellent but not very active. If people want good fb amphibian groups there better off joining "amphibian keepers forum" or "Newts and salamanders" both of which have very experienced breeders from around the world and the info and pics are superb. In the latter group we currently have a Mexican posting pics of various Ambystoma in his captive breeding program which are generally not held in captivity, Steffen Hellner talking about A.andersoni , he was the first person to bring them to the EU and breed them and a whole host of other great posts.
 
Suzi , your info is pretty good BTW, your group however sucks.
 
No offence taken at all! I know exactly what u mean, u can't see anyone's rep on Facebook witch does make it hard to know who to listen too. And there are some people who don't know what a cycle is and then try to give advice on tanks.. But hey I can't kick them out cos they don't know what there talking about lol I do try to make sure that wrong info isn't given.
If it were up to me it would be different but the other admins are more soft, and I'm a little but mean.. Haha
 
At Ian:
Lmao!! Yes I know.. I am aware it's not the best!! But hey what can I do when there's 4 other admins who don't agree with me like .. Ever! Lol
 
Inexperienced mods are the problem in fb groups. If you look at the caudata.org mods in comparison you can see the difference, they are all experienced amphibian breeders and/or professional people who know what they are talking about. I left axolotlaholics as I couldn't stomach the bs , the founder Joanne was pretty good but she wasn't very active unfortunately, I actually upset a couple of the mods on there by pulling them up on incorrect info they responded by booting my son out of the group. Not that he was overly concerned, I had recommended that he join to make himself aware of some of the incorrect info perpetuated about axolotls online and try to counteract some of it.
 
Suzie, your posts aren't in question! But there are several others spreading misinformation and myths, and because they 'read it on the internet' from someone else with as little experience as them they assume it MUST be true.

I appreciate the value of debate and discussion. Suzie is right though, there is no way on FB to distinguish between newbies without a clue and experienced or professional keepers like there is on here with the reputation system.

For the record, I am also a member of the newt & salamander group, the BAKS group and Axolotls UK, 3 pet rehoming groups (including an axie specific one) and I set up Billie's page so I could share my (Billie's) thoughts. The groups don't necessarily need admins, they need a way to separate good advice from experienced people from bad info, and for people to take advice when it's given and stop being defensive over their mistakes.

I can see 'Billie' having a rant .....!
 
I totally agree! With everything said! There needs to be some sort of rules with giving advice, and if u give wrong advice u shouldn't be aloud to give any more wrong advice!
 
I have found that the most active members in fb groups tend to be those with the least to say. Many experienced keepers get fed up of argueing the toss about care requirements with people who's main experience in keeping axolotls is killing them. I post very little in fb forums but advise people who ask me questions by pm, if they don't take my advice its not a problem but they don't get any more lol.
 
I have looked at every lotl-related site I could find, trying to learn all I can about axolotls, but this is the only site offering information I feel I can trust. I still wonder how Caudata's reputation system works, and whether 'likes' should have any influence when people can gain 'likes' for posts with little or no knowledge content (eg the OP 'likes' someone's post saying how cute the OP's lotl is). However, it rapidly becomes obvious here who is an expert and has the experience to know what they're talking about. Naming no names, but we all know who they are! Thanks heaps guys.

And just to remind us all why Caudata is such a valuable resource, I relate this anecdote: a friend just told me that in his childhood (about 15 years ago), his mother morphed an axolotl by lowering the water level, following instructions in a book! OMG!! He was horrified when I said this was cruel, as his mother would never deliberately harm any creature. And after all, he said, it lived a 'normal' lifespan (two years!). But the point is that this book told its readers how to torture a lotl. Something fun to do with your kids. Makes your blood boil, doesn't it?

So on behalf of all helpless captive axies and their often well-meaning but ignorant keepers, thank you so much, Caudata!
 
I still wonder how Caudata's reputation system works, and whether 'likes' should have any influence when people can gain 'likes' for posts with little or no knowledge content

I don't think the likes count as reputation. You can see how many likes someone has been given on their profile, but only what is given via the reputation icon next to the post counts as reputation. At least that's what I think, correct me if I'm wrong? :D
 
Likes on here are the same value as likes on facebook - it's just a popularity contest! It's the little scales icon that counts. But not everyone's rep counts, you have to have reputation points to be able to give reputation! It's complicated, but there is an explanation if you click the word 'rep' by the scale symbol.

So if a newbie gives you good/bad rep it doesn't count, but if someone with a good rep gives you the thumbs up or down it does. And you can't give rep points to the same person too many times, you get a pop-up that tells you to 'share the love'!

This site at least has a way of telling who has been around the block and knows their stuff, and I'm grateful I found this site before I got my first axies.
 
I see a lot of misinformation on the two axolotl facebook groups I participate in and on caudata.org. Facebook seems to be a little worse. The internet offers lots of opportunity for good information and bad information. The problem is sorting it out.
 
Somebody posted this thread in axolotlaholics, apparently I need " to work on my interpersonal skills" ....... The group has decided to make some well justified changes into how its run, which surprised me a great deal as I didn't think it was "run". Either way a step in the right direction for a group with such a large following. It appears that that the forces of STUPID are being put to flight. Does anybody have an address for Carlos Webb ? I want to pop round and say " Hi".
 
When you see Carlos give him a hug from me. Has he been invited to be a new moderator?
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top