I've got two in the lab that I'll raise through metamorphosis, photographing them along the way. I'll let you know what they turn out to be.
@Pierson - From what I have seen in S MS, dwarf salamander larvae can be really variable. I have found larger larval dwarf salamanders that have similar striations to the one in your photo, but I have also found them in this part of the region without striations. As for the dorsolateral spots in the larvae in my photos, they appear to be different from the spots on larval four-toed salamanders. It seems like the spots on four-toeds are a bit larger, much more dorsal with little space between the rows, and they often have some sort of color (yellow or chestnut). Larval Eurycea cirrigera and sometimes Eurycea guttolienata have similarly spaced, small light spots, which, from what I understand, are aggregations of iridophores around the lateral line organs. So I don't think that it's unlikely that small, larval dwarf salamanders might also have dorsolateral spots. It's also worth pointing out that what we call Eurycea quadridigitata is likely a species complex, so that might explain some of the regional differences in larvae.
Another key feature that appears to hold for H. scutatum is that the dorsal fin origin is anterior to or at least at the midbody point, whereas for E. quadridigitata, it is not.