Hi dalabrae,
Yes it’s quite true that not all blue-eyed white cats are deaf. What you have to remember with the blue-eyed white cat is that (genetically) there’s several ways to produce them. For example, we know that the Dominant white gene in cats is a masking gene, so it will hide or mask the true pattern of the coat. Both WW and Ww produce a white coat no matter what their underlying genetics are. So you may have a cat that is blue-eyed, but this has been caused by a totally different gene. If your cat is also a colourpoint (say, having the Siamese coat pattern) the blue eyes may come from this source. It’s only problematic when the eyes are blue through the delay of pigment cells migrating from the neural crest, and it is this that causes the iris to lack pigmentation.
It should be noted though that the Dominant White gene in cats is variable in its effect, and as such there’s three possible eye colours. The first is normal orange eyes, odd-eyed, and blue. With odd-eyed, basically you can visually observe that the pigments have reached one eye but not the other. With orange, the pigments have migrated successfully. The third effect, the blue eyes, is often an indicator of problems and a proportion of these cats are deaf. These effects are well documented and are consistently produced, however like I’ve mentioned above there is quite a variable expression of this syndrome, so a white cat may only be mildly affected and have a white coat, orange eyes and normal hearing, where as at the other end of the spectrum the extreme expression of the gene may produce a white coat, blue eyes and deaf in both ears.
You are quite right regarding the “smudge” seen in kittens. This usually disappears as they age, but breeders use this as a guideline, and it seems statistically that these smudges indicate that they have received more functional melanocytes than their siblings, and as such they seem to be less severely affected.
With tortoiseshell you are talking about the O gene in cats. A similar gene in hamsters also exists ( “To” gene) which produces a very similar phenotype. These genes differ from all other colour genes because they are sex linked, so the mode of inheritance is different. Just quickly referring back to the blue-eyed white cat, in some animals the blue-eyed white trait is sex linked. This isn’t the case for cats and the trait occurs equally in both males and females. The gene is carried on an autosome ( a chromosome other than the X or Y sex chromosome)
In tortoiseshell cats, males do exist, but are exceptionally rare, and arise through mishaps in the transmission of the X or Y chromosomes. These males may have Klinefelters syndrome and carry an extra X chromosome, or may even be chimeras, which are the result of the fusion of two differently coloured embryos.
The tri-coloured cat is the result of combining two genes, the tortoisehell and the white spotting gene (S), which shouldn’t be confused with the Dominant white gene. In cats the S gene is very variable in effect. It is an incomplete dominant gene so SS cats will carry more white than Ss. However there is so much variability in its expression that breeders often find it difficult to distinguish between the two genotypes. With extreme expression of this gene in SS individuals, they may appear to have a fully white coat, and may also have blue eyes, but are rarely deaf.
Hope this helps,
Ed