Sponge Bed Substrate?

Jonjey

Banned
Joined
Apr 25, 2014
Messages
285
Reaction score
9
Points
0
Location
North Carolina
Country
United States
Display Name
Jeff
Has anyone ever tried using a flat layer of aquarium sponge as the bed of their aquarium? Are there any draw backs to this idea? I'm thinking it will be comfy for the Axolotl's, it'll be extremely easy to clean being that I can just take a block at a time out and shake it off in a bucket of dechlorinated water than put it back in place, it would be great for beneficial bacteria and it will more than likely look really really cool. I currently use aquarium sand and it works fine, I'm just always thinking of different ideas to try out and this one seems rather promising.
 
Huh. I've never really thought about doing that, interesting idea. I don't see any problem with it - it would indeed be a great place for beneficial bacteria to live, and as long as the sponge is meant for aquarium use I don't see why not.
 
The only thing I can think to it being a problem is that it may trap a lot of waste from escaping food and axolotl waste.
 
I recommend never ever feeding blackworms if you choose to do this. Those little guys get into everything and are a pain to get out of the filter sponges. Maybe you can get ahold of a denser type of sponge?
 
I recommend never ever feeding blackworms if you choose to do this. Those little guys get into everything and are a pain to get out of the filter sponges. Maybe you can get ahold of a denser type of sponge?

Black worms are too expensive anyway! Haha, I just ordered two of these;
49x49cm Black Filtration Foam Aquarium Fish Tank Biochemical Filter Sponge Pad | eBay
One funny thing that I recently learned is that aquarium sponge floats until bacteria grows on it so I'll have to have my tank covered by sponges for a few days before I can try it out haha.
Thinking of having a few spots with no sponge and either bare or just some sand in those spots, mostly where I have my rock cave constructions because I don't have anything glued/siliconed together all my rock caves are just rocks assembled in a fashion where they won't fall over so I don't want to have to redo them every time I shake my sponge bed out.
I feed blood worms to the guy that's in the tank atm. Out of a little upside down seashell that works very well as a dish as he can stick his head right in there to grab them while not making a huge mess.
 
let us know how this works over time - curious if it has positive or negative affect on water quality. I could see gluing river rocks to sponge, to give a more natural look but still gaining some of the benefits.
 
I'm also wondering if I can use this siliconed to the sides of vivariums and put moss blend all over it. Lots of interesting possibilities.
 
Has anyone ever tried using a flat layer of aquarium sponge as the bed of their aquarium? Are there any draw backs to this idea? I'm thinking it will be comfy for the Axolotl's, it'll be extremely easy to clean being that I can just take a block at a time out and shake it off in a bucket of dechlorinated water than put it back in place, it would be great for beneficial bacteria and it will more than likely look really really cool. I currently use aquarium sand and it works fine, I'm just always thinking of different ideas to try out and this one seems rather promising.
One idea if you are able to would use these above an under gravel filtration system. Just an idea on my part, these could act as an extra filter for your filter and would look decent on the bottom of your tank. But all in all, I think they would work as a substrate. After all never know unless it is tried.
 
I'm an inveterate tinkerer, so I can say yes sponge works as a bottom substrate, so does the filter media mats. As to blackworms. That I don't feed. The follow work. Slate over undergravel filter or sponge or matting over undergravel filter. Courser reticulated filter foam in the 30-45 ppm range rinse much more easily and thoroughly than 60-100 which eventually plug with fines or algae and don't hold up to a lot of squish and rinse.

Yep sponge as moss mat objects works great! Or moss wall. I tack moss to it with fishing line and an upholstery needle, then you don't see the stitching. Undergravel, a filtermat then sand prevents anaerobic build up and the mat keeps the sand from sifting through.

I use a small cannister filter over a powerhead or airstone powered undergravel because I can set it up reverse flow. The cannister pushes water under the sand or mat or sponge, and up very diffused into aquarium where the intake tube, with a sponge prefilter removes the wastes. Less settles, less clogs, less chance of bed failure.

If its a small quiet cannister, it makes practically no noise. Unlike power filters, airstones, powerheads.

Also consider a simple trimmed down high quality, closed cell Eva exercise mat. Food,water and chemically impervious they are simpler to use in aquaria than many foams. They come in puzzle tiles that fit together.Just avoid the cheap ones, one solid color all the way through, no paint or coloring on top.

I get mine used from closing gyms, yoga studios etc. Or buy new and check the msds first to be sure.

I'll stop now. I've been a tinker for wayyyy too long.
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top