Tank not cycling, please help!

Cthulhu

New member
Joined
Nov 17, 2014
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
New York
Country
United States
Display Name
Paige
Ok so it has been MONTHS of me doing frequent water changes, using dechlorinater, monitoring water parameters just about daily, adding carbon, etc. I've been doing everything to cycle my 15 gallon tank and i just can't.

I got to a nitrite spike, and it stayed there, i got annoyed so i did a slightly larger water change, and now im back down to having ammonia :confused:

I seriously dont know what to do, and i've been diligent for months. I've gone to exotic pet stores and fish shops to get advice, read every article i could on here, everything.

I just cant cycle my tank. What should i do? Should i get a bigger tank and try a fish less cycle? Get a bigger filter? Please help :c

i'm worried for my axies health and i want her to be happy and healthy as possible. I don't think im a bad owner, i do everything i can for her. I just feel so bad that the tank wont cycle and i dont want her being sick/stressed because of me...
 
To cycle an aquarium, you need to cycle before you place any sort of animal inside. Chemical spikes are hurtful to even the hardiest of fish. To cycle an aquarium, the method I used was to set up the aquarium as I wanted, filters and all. I then added some betta food to feed the bacteria(as the food decays, ammonia is released). Then I put nutrafin cycle into my aquarium. Cycle is bacteria in a bottle, it contains all the good Bactria you need for a balanced aquarium. I have never had any issues with cycling. If I were in your position, I would try to see if your lfs will board you axy for a little while you take care of things. The effects of an imbalanced aquarium are devastating to the overall health of an axolotl. Ammonia and nitrite burns their gills. Your cycle might take some time, but some things you can do to speed it up are: use pre existing filter media, use cycle, and use the same ornaments as bacteria lives there.
 
While the preferred cycling method is fishless (axolotl-less), generally you can safely cycle a tank with the fish (axolotl) in the tank, as long as you do frequent enough water changes to keep the ammonia and nitrites low. (It sounds like you have been doing this. :happy:) While these water changes might lengthen the cycle time, the tank should still cycle within 6 weeks.

Generally (but not always), if a cycle takes months, there is some issue with how you are handling the tank. A big water change should not have "reset" the cycle.

So, can you provide more details? What pH? What dechlorinator? Are you dechorinating the water before it goes in the tank? Are you cleaning the filter, and if so, are you cleaning it in dechlorinated water? What kind of filter?

Here are a couple of notions for you to consider. These are long-shots.
1) Does your water have chloramine or does your supplier use a higher level of chlorination than typical? That would require a larger dose of most dechlorinators. It would also explain your observation that after a big water change, you saw ammonia again.
2) Has the tank been re-sealed with a household silicone sealer instead of an aquarium sealer? This could explain a failure-to-cycle, since many household silicone sealers have antimicrobial additives.
 
Laura asked some great questions, but I'll add, what filter media do you use in your filter? I ask because I find it best to forget carbon and stick to filter floss, sponges, and something like a ceramic media.
 
Laura, I really appreciate you getting back to me and helping me out!

When I tested the water yesterday these were my water conditions

pH: around 7.2
Ammonia: 0.25 ppm
nitrites: 0 ppm
nitrates: 0 ppm

I believe I use the tetrafin dechlorinator, I wash the filter with dechlorinated water, and I always use it before doing water changes. I even let the water sit out for a day to make sure it's safe. I have a small sponge based filter with a spray bar, it's smaller but it's suited for the size of the tank. I have a 15 gallon.

Even though I cleaned the aquarium very well before I got it, it might be a reptile aquarium and not a fish tank aquarium. I can't be totally sure. Could this be the reason the tanks not cycling because. I'll also look up the water conditions in my area
 
Just take a sponge filter from a good tank and set up in the bad tank. That is all I use. It works every time because the sponge will have all the bacteria you need.
 
Lol I don't have another tank, this is the only tank I have and the first tank I've ever seriously had. I don't know where I'd get some good tank media
 
You could get some used tank media from another aquarist or LFS maybe, but doing it this way I would recommend you do it from someone you trust to have healthy fish.

If you want to make it easier on yourself you could put your axie in a small plastic container (food safe) and change his water daily in there while you do a fish-less cycle on your tank. It'll make it easier on you and you won't have to change as much water as you would in the big tank, but you would have to change it at least daily and test to make sure the water is clean. I've never done it like this but read of many who do it.

Any chance we can see a picture of the sponge filter? I'm wondering if maybe you have one that's too small? When I got my axie his tank never cycled at first. I had a small filter that works for 10 gallons but would get dirty and clog up really fast. I changed filters, put in a good amount of media in there and it cycled quickly.
 
If the sponge is undersized, that would definitely be a problem. Axolotls tend to generate a lot of ammonia.

Do you know if you have ever seen nitrates? I know have been changing the water a lot lately, so that might not be a good indicator, but once you start seeing nitrates, you know the cycle is close to established. If you have seen nitrates, then that would be another indication that maybe the tank is just too small.

That pH should not affect the cycle, and also is low enough that ammonia is not particularly toxic.

Given the amount of time you have been spending with water changes, Cacique's suggestion to do an axolotl-less cycle might be the best approach, particularly if you decide you need a bigger filter.

If you do get another filter, rinse it in water that you have squeezed out of the old one. It may or may not speed the cycle much, but logic suggests is should help speed it up a little. If you decide not to do a axolotl-less cycle, run both filters in the tank for a couple of weeks.
 
Thank you guys for all of the replies and help! I was able to get a much larger tank and I'm doing a fishless cycle with that one. With the tank my axie is in right now I've made a big effort in cleaning out the sponge frequently and that seems like it's been help a ton! The water condition has been much better and her gills seem much fuller.

As the large tank cycles (where I can move her into hopefully soon) I've been doing frequent water changes with a different water conditioner. She seems much more active and has more of an appetite. So I think for now ill make sure I clean the filter out with dechlorinated water (since I can't get a bigger filter to filter her tank at the moment). But thank you again for all of the advice!
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top