Topless tank

mwebber

New member
Joined
Dec 2, 2012
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Berkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Hi there, a bit of an odd question but here goes:
I was looking for some tanks for my paddletails and a couple of species I am interested in getting, when I came across a strange open bay like tank for sale which is clearly meant for turtles or terrapins, however it came with a whole variety of stuff and was so cheap I had to snap it up as it would be rude to waste such an opportunity, however. I am now wondering what I should keep in this open tank, it has both terrestrial and aquatic areas and is quite large, easily big enough and deep enough for a few musk turtles but I don't wish to keep turtles as I have had my fix of terrapins for now. Does anybody have any suggestions for any good caudates or general amphibs which I could keep in this set up (it has filter and capability of u.v. and heat lamp etc if required).
Cheers :D
 
Hi,

this answer would seem a little disappointing, but I suggest you do a little research yourself. From your question it seems like you don't know anything about keeping newts (they will escape open tanks, never need U.V., especially don't need heat lamps). If you are looking for an animal to fit your setup, I dont think caudates are the right choice, you will have to modify it a little.
Noone here can tell you what newt to take, you have to choose yourself and then build him a habitat that suits him. You cannot do it the other way around.

Greetings,
Jakob
 
Hi Jakob,

No I obviously know that I will need to get some sort of lid made for the tank in order to prevent any newts escaping, that goes without saying. I think we are going to disagree about the need for u.v. as the former beliefs about most amphibs and u.v. are currently being re-thought, some species of caudate will still benefit from even low levels of u.v, especially tricky feeders which can't have food suitably dusted (or the nutrients are reduced if the animal takes a while to consume). The statement about heating etc was only a brief description of what is equipped with the tank currently, if I kept a caudate it would be kept cold-cool, as a wise man once said about some caudates: "keep them cool, and they are cool". I merely was looking for suggestions of interesting or exciting species which I could keep as I already keep some of the more run of the mill pet shop species, and am looking for something a bit more out there. Thanks anyway.

Mick
 
Hi,

this answer would seem a little disappointing, but I suggest you do a little research yourself. From your question it seems like you don't know anything about keeping newts (they will escape open tanks, never need U.V., especially don't need heat lamps). If you are looking for an animal to fit your setup, I dont think caudates are the right choice, you will have to modify it a little.
Noone here can tell you what newt to take, you have to choose yourself and then build him a habitat that suits him. You cannot do it the other way around.

Greetings,
Jakob

I'm sure a lid could be easily created, plus he wasn't suggesting he used UV on newts. The question was about amphibians in general, many of which do in fact require UV lighting.
 
Few species will make use of both terrestrial and aquatic areas. Most available ones are either fully aquatic or fully terrestrial (except perhaps for brief periods during the breeding season), so aquaterrariums are for the most part a waste of time and space.
The UV light is pointless in caudates. There are some amphibians that do indeed benefit from some UV radiaion but cadates are not among them. Terrestrial ones are unlikely to do much out in the open when there´s still light and aquatic ones get no benefit as the water filters it out. Luckily, it´s not needed at all and a good diet is more than enough to meet their needs.
If you post pictures of the tank we might be able to make some suggestions.
 
I shall be getting the tank on Saturday so will upload a picture then. If it proves a bit useless as combined I may just remove the water and fill with moss and bark etc for some marbled newts or some such. Or I may have to delve back into the world of semi-aquatic chelonia. :)
 
I have two smaller open-top Exo Terra turtle tanks, and they work great if you modify them appropriately. I started by cutting commercial frames for 15 gallon aquariums so that they would fit the slightly larger and angled turtle tank. The frame pieces were attached with black silicone, and the gaps filled, smoothed, and taped flat. Then I got about 10 feet of three-inch back-trim. This is black plastic which is cuut to length and fitted to a glass lid, allowing the trim to be cut around cords and pumps while still covering the back section of an aquarium. This I also cut to fit...BUT...I cut it to fit onto the FRAME, on the inside edge. This gives a removable three-inch overhang all the way around, which allows me to remove portions of it for maintenance. The inhabitants are Cynops [aquatic] and Hynobius [fossorial], and in a couple of years operation it has worked great with zero problems. The vegetation includes a couple trees which have grown double the tank height, but so long as the air [central heating in an arid climate for me] is dry and the animals not normally climbers, escape is extremely unlikely. Jumping or climbing species would require more security.
 
Any chance of pictures, FrogEyes?
 
Wow frogeyes that sounds great, if you had some pictures for inspiration that would be cool.
Cheers
 
These two pics show the layout of the tank, it has this weird bowed outward shape which is going to mean making a lid is tricky. These pics aren't of my set up they are internet stolen but the same product. Upon reflection it looks like it may have to be a small turtle tank not for anything amphib (well it can be for tadpole rearing until I can find black-knobbed map turtles, blandings turtle or spotted turtles). Unless anybody has any amazing lid making ideas or completely non-climbing caudate species?
Thanks :)
 

Attachments

  • tortoise tank.jpg
    tortoise tank.jpg
    11.3 KB · Views: 11,128
  • turtle tank.jpg
    turtle tank.jpg
    245.3 KB · Views: 52,893
Perhaps African dwarf frogs? Dwarf sirens? There are some non-climbing caudates, but most of them need a much larger water area (like axolotls, sirens, mudpuppies).
 
It is quite a substantial size tank, I would estimate potential for at least 150 litres of water, more if things are non-climbing. Dwarf-sirens are an interesting idea, I hadn't thought of them; time for some heavy research. Cheers
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top