I'm leaning towards a tiger, probably an eastern tiger, based on bits of pattern I can make out in the dark areas. If you know where it came from, it would help.
If you know where it came from, it would help.
Same, but the lack of spots is confusing. Is this common for Eastern's to have not that many spots?
In Indiana, it would be A.tigrinum. While the shadows seem to hide patterns typical of tigers, those markings are also NOT characteristic of any other eastern mole salamander.
It looks like a north western, A gracile to me?